About 20 minutes later, Judge Cannone returned to say the jury had reached a second verdict. In his interview with TMZ, Jason explained jurors went back for additional discussions on the OUI charge. He says they ultimately came to the same conclusion as they had in the first verdict, which remains under seal and unavailable for public review.

During arguments over verdict slip confusion, defense attorney Alan Jackson warned Judge Cannone that the second trial could end in a similar way. "We are going to end up in the exact same position that we were in last year," Jackson told the judge during the tense exchange Tuesday.